Figuring out, Fixing, and Stopping Cannibalization — Whiteboard Friday

The creator’s views are completely their very own (excluding the unlikely occasion of hypnosis) and should not all the time replicate the views of Moz.

On this Whiteboard Friday, Jon discusses tips on how to establish, repair, and stop cannibalization. He identifies three particular sorts of cannibalization: inner, worldwide, and subdomain.

Digital whiteboard on the topic 'Identifying, Fixing, and Preventing Cannibalization'

Click on on the whiteboard picture above to open a excessive decision model in a brand new tab!

Video Transcription

Hey, Moz followers. How’s it going? My title is Jon Earnshaw. I am the Chief Product Evangelist at Pi Datametrics, and at the moment I’ll be speaking a few topic that’s tremendous near my coronary heart, and it has been near my coronary heart for over 15 years. After I was analyzing the SERP at some point and I began to find this uncommon flux, and what I used to be seeing was content material that was doing rather well on web page 1 and all of a sudden it drops.

Then after a couple of weeks, we seen that it wasn’t dropping for no cause. This content material was dropping on account of different content material one way or the other conflicting. Now, we all know there isn’t any such factor as a reproduction content material penalty, and Google has all the time mentioned that. However what we now have understood since then is that Google and different search engines like google as nicely have gotten more and more delicate to content material of an analogous nature, and that is what cannibalization is all about.

So at the moment we’re going to check out the way you establish it briefly as a result of you are able to do that with instruments. I’ll present you ways you repair it, and eventually the way you forestall it from occurring within the first place, and should you get that bit proper, you clearly needn’t fear about one or two.

Step 1: Establish the kind of cannibalization

image showing the three types of cannibalization that you need to identify

So cannibalization, there are three varieties. Nicely, there are extra, however there are three varieties that we form of want to concentrate on.

The primary one is inner battle or cannibalization. I will use these phrases interchangeably. That is the place your content material conflicts with itself. Then we now have worldwide battle, and that is a very completely different kettle of fish, as a result of that is handled, for instance, by hreflang. So we’ll preserve that out of the combination.

Then we now have subdomain battle, and subdomain battle is one thing that may all the time occur. For instance, when you’ve got a assist subdomain,, and you have got content material on there that is just like the content material in your principal area, that is all the time going to battle. However we’re not going to speak about that at the moment. Actually, we’ll discuss inner battle and the way you repair it to start out with.

Step 2: Repair cannibalization points

image showing step two for fixing cannibalization

So lets say you get up at some point, you have been on web page 1 for “males’s blazers.” All of us need to be on web page 1 if we’re promoting males’s blazers. Then all of a sudden you discover your content material drops. Then whenever you take a more in-depth look, you would possibly uncover that you’ve a number of URLs returning over a time frame for a similar key phrase. Some extent to notice about cannibalization, it occurs at key phrase stage.

It is not content material stage. It is all in regards to the key phrase. So one piece of content material might not be in battle for one more time period, for a by-product time period, for instance “males’s jackets” or “males’s summer season jackets,” and that web page might exist superbly on web page 1. However lets say that you’ve one, two, three, 4 pages.

These may very well be males’s summer season blazers, males’s winter blazers, males’s 2023 blazers, for instance. The possibilities are if these pages are related and in the event that they include the key phrase that you just’re making an attempt to place for, i.e., “males’s blazers,” within the title, chances are high you are going to get battle as a result of we all know that the HTML title is among the strongest indicators to Google from a theming perspective.

URL, title, Header 1, meta description, content material, all of that counts. However you may discover whenever you make adjustments to the title, that may have a fairly instantaneous influence on visibility in lower than 24 hours. So again to our state of affairs of cannibalization. For URLs, what can we need to do? Nicely, we have to decide.

Which one can we need to be the doorway into our ecosystem? As a result of if we do not decide on which one is the doorway into our ecosystem, then Google goes to make that call for us and we’ll find yourself in a state of affairs of cannibalization. Cannibalization, it may very well be in line. It may all be occurring on the backside of web page 1. Generally folks say, “Nicely, I am on web page 1, however I do not actually care.”

However it is best to care, as a result of think about your viewers are looking for the lads’s blazer they usually discover your piece of content material they usually find it irresistible, they usually come again the following day they usually Google it once more, they usually discover it once more, “Oh, it is a completely different web page.” They go into the location in a special space. Abruptly, I am confused as a result of we have incoherent, uncoordinated, and haphazard doorways into our world.

So we have to make the choice and never go away that to the various search engines. There are a selection of issues that we are able to do to really repair this. However the very first thing we have to do is examine the place of the URLs for different phrases, for by-product phrases. Do these items of content material place in their very own proper?

Earlier than we begin tampering, earlier than we begin taking part in with titles, earlier than we begin redirecting, earlier than we do something, do they place in their very own proper? Then we now have selections to make. One attainable alternative, and I’ve seen plenty of shoppers do that, is to really merge one of many older bits of content material and put that in with the brand new content material, and that works splendidly as a result of we’re not shedding something.

So we merge that, after which, in fact, we 301 the unique article. So we instantly get that injection of authority. Okay, downgrade the theme. How do you downgrade the theme? Keep in mind the title, the strongest ingredient on the web page? We will truly change the title so it isn’t about males’s blazers. We will say “males’s outfits for the summer season,” if that is applicable.

Once more, let’s not try this if that web page positions in its personal proper as a result of we do not need to lose that site visitors. We will additionally examine the site visitors to the web page as nicely. Internally hyperlink. If we determine, for instance, that A is the web page that we need to be our doorway, let’s give it the authority that it must place.

Let’s hyperlink internally from B, C, and D to A utilizing the anchor textual content “males’s blazers.” What are we doing? Nicely, we’re saying to Google this web page over right here is all about males’s blazers, and the anchor textual content and people hyperlinks are going to offer that web page the authority that it wants.

So we try this along side a few of these different choices. We will additionally No Index if applicable. So we now have numerous instruments in our arsenal. However simply think about that we love all of those pages and we do not need to lose these as a result of that is summer season blazers, winter blazers, linen blazers, and different blazers.

One other factor that you are able to do, in case your CMS permits, is to really construct a hub web page. Let’s name that hub web page Males’s Blazers, and let’s hyperlink down from the brand new web page, name that Web page X, Males’s Blazers, to this one utilizing the anchor textual content “summer season blazers,” to this one, Winter, Linen, and many others. Then crucially, we take the interior linking right here and we hyperlink again from all of those to the hub web page.

What have we created there? This excellent hub and spoke construction inside our website that your viewers are going to make sense of and Google goes to make sense of it as nicely. So actually it is about sending indicators to Google in order that Google would not get confused.

So that is all the way down to us as a result of the search engine is extremely delicate. In order that’s how one can repair it, and you have got numerous selections.

Step 3: Forestall cannibalization

Lastly, my favourite half, how do you forestall it? How can we not need to undergo this and this? Nicely, the important thing to stopping it truly is to make use of one of many 4 pillars of contextual optimization.

Step 3: Preventing Cannibalization through contextual optimization

Contextual optimization is all about optimizing within the context of the SERP, optimizing within the context of your opponents, optimizing within the context of Google’s algorithms, and optimizing within the context of your ecosystem. So what we imply right here is about earlier than I inject any new content material with reference to males’s blazers into my ecosystem, I’ve obtained to cease and suppose and ask the query, “Is there something inside my ecosystem that’s probably conflicting?”

That is the primary query you ask, as a result of if there are different items of content material within the ecosystem with “males’s blazers” within the title, chances are high they will battle, and it’s possible you’ll find yourself taking one web page of web page 1 of Google and your web page by no means will get to web page 1. So it’s possible you’ll lose out throughout. So a very easy means of analyzing your ecosystem is with a website operator.

So intitle, and also you herald intitle, and we’re in search of, in inverted commas, “males’s blazers” as a result of that is going to return all of the pages out of your website, that Google has listed, which have “males’s blazers” within the title.

Keep in mind, the strongest theme. So we’d discover earlier than we inject the brand new content material, hey, I’ve obtained A, B, C, and D in my ecosystem. So we then return right here, and we make the choice. If this can be a new piece of content material, I can begin to undertake and deploy a number of of those strategies to forestall it from occurring within the first place.

Truthfully, cannibalization of content material is inflicting a lot lack of visibility. I might estimate someplace round 40% of content material that is sitting on web page 2 and three is all the way down to this. Establish the conflicts. As soon as we have performed that, we establish the enhances. How do you establish the enhances and why?

Nicely, I will inform you why. As a result of whenever you put a brand new piece of content material into your ecosystem to go sit alongside these, it wants authority if it is going to carry out nicely, and the very best and quickest means of authority is to get that from different pages on a associated theme that discuss blazers or males’s model or males’s style. We do one other website operator right here,

Neglect the intitle. Let’s search for “males’s blazers” within the physique copy. We will try this, and we are able to discover enhances. As soon as you’ve got discovered the enhances, you need to create hyperlinks utilizing “males’s blazers” because the anchor textual content to your new piece of content material. How do you discover older items of content material?

Inverted commas, “2019” or “2018.” Add that, you may all of a sudden begin to discover older content material that you’ve got completely forgotten about and, along with these hyperlinks, which are going to inject authority. You may then add some redirects. Actually, in a nutshell, that is all there may be to it, figuring out, fixing, and stopping, and I assure these are all going to give you the results you want.

Thanks for watching.

Video transcription by